Every claim, on the record.
Each number below came from a question set locked by hash and a dated measurement, with the method documented in full. Each one is tied to the run that produced it. Nothing here is a vibe.
Predicted before measured
The strongest claim is one made before the data exists. This one was committed to a dated, timestamped record first, then measured.
Claude would cite Honolulu AC companies' own websites less than 5% of the time. Measured at 2%. The commit timestamp predates the first measurement run. Committed to a dated, timestamped record before the measurement ran.
Wording note, added 2026-09-10. The sentence above is reproduced exactly as committed and is not edited, because editing a pre-registered claim after the result is known would defeat the purpose of pre-registering it. The verb is now known to be wrong: Claude searches nothing and returns no URLs, so it names rather than cites, and the 2% is a share of answers that name the business, not of cited URLs. The prediction and the result are unaffected. See the two-layer correction on the methodology page, dated 2026-09-06.
Across October 2026, fewer than 10 percent of the pages ranking in classic search's organic top five will also be cited by the AI answer engines asked the same question on the same day. Open. Result due 2026-11-01. We do not know it yet either.
What would make us wrong: Pooled overlap at or above 20 percent means classic ranking and AI citation are substantially the same thing on these questions, and we say so in public.
Disclosure. Exploratory 14-day sample seen 2026-09-15 before committing. Overlap 1.5 to 3.4 percent per engine, on the pre-correction definition of cited_urls. The October window is out of sample and uses the corrected instrument.
The published claims
47 numbers across 11 measurements. Each block names the date it was measured, the hash that locks the question set, and links to the full teardown it came from.
Hawaii consumer banking
- Perplexity own-share (top of 75-pt spread): 75%
- Bing organic own-share (bottom of spread): 0%
- web own-site share: 53%
Hawaii wealth management
- Claude own-share: 38%
- Gemma own-share (top of table): 68%
- web own-site share: 47%
Honolulu dental practices
- Google AI Overviews own-share: 62%
- Bing organic own-share: 0%
- web own-site share: 44%
Hawaii law firms
- Claude own-share: 51%
- web own-site share: 35%
Hawaii CPA firms
- OpenAI own-share: 60%
- Claude own-share: 1%
- Gemma own-share: 2%
Austin TX CPA firms (cross-geo)
- Claude own-share: 0%
- Gemma own-share: 23%
Honolulu med spas
- Gemini own-share (top of table): 64%
- ChatGPT search own-share: 57%
- Claude own-share (the collapse): 2%
- Gemma own-share: 32%
- Bing organic own-share: 0%
- web own-site share: 51%
Honolulu HVAC
- ChatGPT search own-share (top): 66%
- Claude own-share (the predicted collapse): 2%
- Gemma own-share (61pp above Claude): 63%
- Bing organic own-share: 0%
- web own-site share (all 5 live-web surfaces, incl the Bing control at 0%): 40%
real_estate_honolulu
- Gemini own-share (top): 28%
- Gemma own-share: 20%
- Claude own-share (the inversion): 18%
- ChatGPT search own-share: 1%
- Bing organic own-share: 0%
- web own-site share (most aggregator-dominated category): 14%
hotels_hawaii
- Claude own-share (top): 47%
- Gemma own-share: 42%
- ChatGPT search own-share: 30%
- Gemini own-share: 12%
- Bing organic own-share: 0%
- hotel-owned share / boutique-beats-chain: 47%
agency_us
- Gemma own-share (top): 39%
- Gemini own-share: 16%
- Perplexity own-share: 14%
- Google AI Overviews own-share: 9%
- Claude own-share: 3%
- Bing organic own-share: 2%
- ChatGPT search own-share: 1%
- agency-owned site share across all engines: 12%
Why this page exists
Most marketing claims cannot be checked. These can. Every number above came from a question set locked by hash, on a named date, with the method documented in full at /methodology. A claim tied to a dated, hash-locked run is a different kind of claim than one that is not, and a vendor whose work is not actually measured cannot publish a page like this.